Clinical Considerations
Developmental neurotoxicity is assessed by experimental testing
for end points that span from structural down to functional problems,
including fetal death, malformations, altered growth and, lastly,
functional abnormalities.
We know much more than ever before about the exquisite vulnerability
of the developing nervous system and the subtle degrees of impairment
that can occur with even low level exposures to certain contaminants
in the environment. However, our knowledge is limited as to understanding
the exact causal mechanisms of most neurodevelopmental disorders,
particularly with respect to the functional and behavioural deficits
and regarding individual clinical cases.
A recent report by the Greater Boston’s Physicians for Social Responsibility
(GBPSR), In Harm’s Way,5
identifies a number of fundamental challenges to diagnosing
the precise cause of observed cognitive and behavioural disorders:
- Prime among these is the fact that cognitive functions and behaviour
are influenced by the "integration of multiple structural
and functional factors with cultural and social forces…(making)
it exceedingly difficult to study the contribution of each factor
independently."6 Determining the
role that environmental factors play toward that development adds
an additional layer of complexity.
- In addition, there may be a long lag time between exposure
and symptoms, perhaps even a generation. For example, a mother’s
exposure while pregnant may produce effects seen only in the child’s
later development. Also, exposures to neurotoxicants early in
life may not lead to appreciable changes until adulthood. Parkinson’s
disease is one such disease speculated to have an early environmental
origin.
The effects from neurotoxicants are chiefly not as dramatic as
gross malformations, but are subclinical in nature and reflect
conditions that are difficult to accurately diagnose.
There is increased recognition that the so-called "small"
or subclinical changes in neurobehavioural function are frequently
irreversible. These changes may adversely influence IQ, the
ability to learn or adjust socially, and the long-term results on
a broader level, such as higher school drop-out rates, increased
rates of violent behaviour and lack of success, are devastating
to us as a society.
The adverse effects from a number of these substances have been
determined largely from animal experiments and limited epidemiological
studies. They are often subtle, although measurable. Effects are
mainly subclinical, and it may be that a physician discovers them
incidentally.
|
The clinical picture upon exposure to neurotoxins
is challenging to define. It is unlikely that such symptoms
will be the primary reason for a patient’s visit. Some of
the functional effects associated with exposure to neurotoxins
may include:
|
The authors of In Harm’s Way describe an "epidemic
of developmental, learning and behavioral disabilities"8
among American children, estimating that nearly 17% (12 million)
suffer from some form of neurodevelopmental or neurobehavioural
condition.
|
"Learning disabilities is a generic
term that refers to a heterogeneous group of disorders due
to identifiable or inferred central nervous system dysfunction. Such disorders may be manifested by delays in early development
and/or difficulties in any of the following areas: attention,
memory, reasoning, coordination, communicating, reading, writing,
spelling, calculation, social competence and emotional maturation."
Learning Disabilities
Association of Canada
|
There are no comparable figures for the prevalence of such conditions
among Canadian children, although there is a sense among schooleachers
and physicians that learning disabilities and attention deficit
disorders have increased substantially in recent decades.9
(A recent Health
Canada survey indicates that 80% of a sample [n=636] of Canadian
physicians reported having seen a child with ADHD at one time.)
It is not clear whether there is indeed a true increase and, if
so, what has caused it; however, health researchers have turned
to an examination of the potential influence of various chemicals
in the environment on children’s neurodevelopment.
|